• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Smoking Chili Media

Digital Marketing Agency in London

  • About Us
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Social Media
    • SEO
      • Ecommerce SEO
    • Email Marketing
    • Facebook PPC Management
    • Website Design
    • Graphic Design
    • Copywriting
    • Video Production
  • Work
    • Portfolio
    • Case Studies
  • BLOG
  • Contact
  • T: 020 3289 5595
  • FREE SEO Analysis
    • Google Review Link Generator

Effects Of The Helpful Content Update: Types Of Sites And Examples

September 19, 2022 By Mac

Google completed the Helpful Content Update rollout on September 9, 15 days after its release began on August 25. Google had announced that it would take two weeks, which turned out to be exact.

And as for its effects? Has it had the desired results described in the Google statement?

Types of content and the sites affected

Based on what has been seen so far, a week after completion, it seems the update has mainly affected obvious and extreme cases of websites with one or more of these characteristics:

Automated, scraped content.

Content taken almost literally from other sources, without adding anything new or of value.

Content created with the excuse of taking advantage of SEO keywords to achieve traffic and monetisation, with nothing new or valuable provided on the topic the user has searched for.

The above practices are equivalent to answering with a clear “yes” to at least three of the nine questions posed by Google in the official announcement of the Helpful Content Update, under the section “Avoid search engine-centric content “.

The examples we will see below usually write to reach a certain number of words, write on topics without having an apparent authority in them, and skim around queries without providing a factual answer.

The most affected niches and topics are entertainment (celebrities, movies, TV), song lyrics, dictionaries or definitions of concepts, technology (software bug fixes and tutorials), and product reviews.

Examples of Impacted Sites

Below we offer examples of sites that seem impacted by the update, given the moment in which they have lost organic visibility, the content they provide, and the indications presented by Google in their guidelines. We have analysed several more sites but, in other cases, do not see patterns as clear as in these.

As the update is very recent, clearer cases have likely escaped our research. The list is incomplete, just a sample of the diverse types of websites affected, and we do not claim to have absolute validity about why they have been affected or even if they deserved it, according to Google’s guidelines. It is purely our opinion.

Nor do we intend to judge the quality of work on those websites. We limit ourselves to showing correlations between their reduced visibility. what we see as professionals, and what Google has communicated it wants to fix with the update. We try to be objective, but we can be wrong. That out of the way; let’s proceed.

Conch-house.com

Conch House is a typical review-type website with scraped content from Amazon, targeting low-difficulty keywords, and built on an expired domain (it was previously the website of a hotel restaurant and received links from TripAdvisor and similar domains). The latter would explain how quickly it grew in organic visibility, just weeks before going down with the Helpful Content Update.

Our data comes from Sistrix. The Sistrix Visibility Index gives a value for a domain’s visibility in Google’s search results. Using the Visibility Index, we can measure success in Google SERPs reliably and transparently.

Conch-house.com once had 27 points of visibility in the Sistrix US index, and now it is down to 0.0157 (virtually zero).

The pattern the content follows is easy to see (the intros promise a “comprehensive guide” to the current product category, and the posts are anything but). The content consists of a spun or patterned introduction, tables created by connecting to the Amazon Affiliate API, and a summary or scrape of reviews for each product.

Wealthycelebrity.com

Wealthy celebrity is a site with information about famous celebrities and not-so-famous celebrities, which tries to answer all possible related keywords (age, wealth, height, spouse/boyfriend, children) around each person. These posts abound in fluff, keyword stuffing, and repetition.

Alphanewscall.com

This site discusses celebrities, movies, TV series, economics, and software. This is a clear violation of the HU without a specific focus and oriented to keywords that may get traffic.

They focused primarily on keywords of the type “celebrity name + net worth”, or “when does the next season of XYZ premiere?” The content implies there is a specific date for a premiere when often, there is not. The resulting article is padded with fluff to keep the user on the page.

After a rapid rise, the site fell first with the May core update and dropped further with the HCU.

En-academic.com

Under the guise of a “legitimate” definition site, en-academic.com contains many pages copied directly from Wikipedia, with the rest, we suspect, coming from other sources, such as scanned books.

Manualzz.com

Manualzz is an aggregator of PDFs of manuals and instructions for products, software, etc. Obviously, none of this is original to the site. They always come from other sources, usually the product’s official website. This site does nothing more than republishing something that already exists without providing any additional value to the user.

Geniuslyrics.net

Here we come across a more complex case to explain, according to the directions from Google. Yes, a lyric site, by definition, doesn’t offer original content, but why has Google dropped some lyric sites and not others?

One possible theory is that sites must have a license from record labels to post the lyrics. Prominent players in the sector, such as genius.com, which the update has not impacted, display license information. Genius Lyrics and the other affected sites of this type would not meet this requirement; they do not display license information on any of their pages.

There are multiple examples of lyrics sites with sudden drops in visibility:

Similar examples with an almost identical loss of visibility pattern include lyricsjonk.com, lyricsroll.com, lyricsfa.com, and lyricsgoo.com.

What to expect for the future

As is often the case when Google announces a new algorithm, part of the industry had taken Google’s words in a big way and braced for a catastrophic impact.

Given these expectations, the observed effect has seemed punctual and not too intense, limited to specific types of sites, in contrast to the more generalised and powerful impact of core updates such as the August 2018 Medic Update.

However, according to Danny Sullivan, representative of Google, the effect has been exactly what was intended and announced. It should not surprise us that it has affected only a tiny percentage of sites since most sites have helpful content according to the criteria.

As Danny Sullivan states, this does not mean that more effects will not be expected in the future. First, the HCU algorithm will still be active, which could affect sites that launch later or add a significant amount of non-useful content down the line.

In addition, Google can refine the classifier, so in the coming months, we will notice more powerful effects on other types of websites (but if Google makes significant changes, they will apparently announce them). The update will be an ongoing effort on Google’s part.

And one more warning from Google. Even if further Helpful Content updates are not released, other updates, such as a core update or a Product Reviews Update, may shift the balance in cases where the HCU has “flagged” a website but not strongly enough to have a visible impact on rankings.

It is also worth remembering that the Helpful Content Update is currently only active for English searches.

 

Related posts:

No related posts.

Filed Under: Features

Primary Sidebar

FOLLOW US ONLINE

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Follow Us On Twitter

Follow @smokingchili

Sign-up to Our Newsletter!

Recent Posts

  • Effects Of The Helpful Content Update: Types Of Sites And Examples
  • Google’s Helpful Content Update: Top Ten Tips for Content Creators
  • 5 Pages Every Business Website MUST Have
  • Why is Social Media So Powerful?
  • What Are Pay Per Click Ads?

Categories

  • Features
  • Industry News

With thanks to:

NB: All the images used on our blog are copyright from www.123rf.com

Footer

GET IN TOUCH:

Smoking Chili Media Ltd
Onega House
112 Main Road
Sidcup
Kent
DA14 6NE

T: 020 3289 5595
E: info@smokingchilimedia.com
W: smokingchilimedia.com

FOLLOW US:

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

ABOUT US:

We are a full service Digital Marketing Agency. We provide specialist SEO, Social Media, UX, Copywriting, Email, Remarketing & SEO optimised Website Design services. So if you’re looking for a Kent SEO Agency who can deliver results, you’ve come to the right place. Let us help you achieve your marketing and design goals today!

FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION:

Contact us for a FREE initial consultation on info@smokingchilimedia.com for further information.
Call Us Now   Email Us Now

OUR GOOGLE REVIEWS:

Google Rating
5.0
Smoking Chili Media
Smoking Chili Media
5.0
Peter Sheridan
Peter Sheridan
08:13 01 Nov 18
Great company to deal with, very responsive and their expertise is second to none.
Selin Gunel
Selin Gunel
12:23 19 Jul 18
Hi from Steps Dance Academy - Great working with Ali, Claire, Darren and the team. Incredibly knowledgable about SEO and fixing issues with our old website code. Always happy to answer any questions we had and have learnt a great deal from working closely with them the past couple of years. Looking forward to more success in the future. Thanks Selin
Matt Reynolds
Matt Reynolds
17:42 25 May 18
MattReynoldsPhotography.co.uk - I'm blown away by the results we've had since starting to work with the Smoking Chili Media team. Leads, inquiries and sales are up since our SEO campaign really kicked in after month 3. The guys are always on hand to help answer any questions we have about the SEO and social media process. So I can't recommend them enough. Great team, great service, great service, great results!  Thanks Matt Reynolds. --
Katie Whitney
Katie Whitney
19:42 11 Jan 18
Just wanted to say a big thank you to Ali and all the team at Smoking Chili Media for all their help with our recent online marketing campaign. They helped us greatly improve our Google Merchant Centre and Google Local presence as well as optimising our site so potential clients could find us through Google natural search. We’ve seen inquiries, phone calls and business increase as a result so we’re happy to recommend them to other businesses in the Bournemouth, Poole and Christchurch area.
Nigel Rumsey
Nigel Rumsey
18:08 22 Dec 17
David Lloyd Leisure - Dartford has been working closely with Smoking Chili Media throughout 2017. Our initial aim was simply to grow our face book following, however the team at Smoking Chilli took this to a whole new level. As well as dramatically increasing our face book following we have seem dramatic increases in member (and indeed non member) engagement creating a real feeling of 'clubiness' throughout our member base. This engagement, as well as amazing in club marketing (thanks Claire) has boosted member attendance at every social event this year which drives our retention as well as additional spend. Smoking Chilli has also been instrumental in raising the profile of the club within the local community which has driven non member club visits, leading to new member sales. If you are looking for a team who will deliver on every level and drive your online marketing to new heights then look no further than Smoking Chili. Thanks guys.
Terry Dempsey
Terry Dempsey
13:03 22 Dec 17
Ali is amazing, knows bucket loads about marketing strategy and has taken our SEO, social media strategy and web site optimisation to a whole new level, Claire is a design legend and now designs our products, Darren is cool as you like and drives the operation forward with his never ending reserves of energy. The rest of the support team are also fantastic. All in all a great team, extremely knowledgeable and accommodating and very happy to recommend them to anyone out there.
Sam Samuel
Sam Samuel
12:38 24 May 17
A very professional and thorough service with attention to detail. The guys were easy to work with, constantly fed back information and results with further recommendations where necessary. Clearly at the forefront of their game we gained a full understanding of what Google recognises as positive. We highly recommend you take a look at this property.
See All Reviews Write a review
powered by Google

CLIENT FEEDBACK:
What our clients say about us:
View Our Testimonials

KEY LOCATIONS:
SEO Dartford
SEO Bromley
SEO Sevenoaks

  • FREE SEO ANALYSIS
  • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Get a Quote
  • LET’S TALK! CALL US ON: 020 3289 5595

Copyright © 2023 · Infinity Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

YES! SEND ME THE FREE TECHNICAL SEO CHECKLIST.